MINUTES
Regular meeting held in Commissioners Meeting Room,
Third Floor, Court House,
MEMBERS PRESENT: Guy Gentry, President; Robert Addington,
Duane Erwin, Gary Michel, and Larry Willis.
Also
present were: Sherri Phillips, Executive Director and Secretary; Leslie
Shively, Attorney; Susan Weigman and Julie Hemmings, staff.
MEMBERS ABSENT: Phil Baxter and Mike Moesner.
MINUTES:
A
motion was made by Larry Willis to approve the minutes of the last regular
meeting of the Area Plan Commission held
The
President explained the Rules of Procedure to the audience.
SUBDIVISIONS FOR PRIMARY PLAT
APPROVAL:
PP-04-06 – Elberfeld Industrial Park
by the Town of Elberfeld, Duane Erwin, Pres. OWNERS: Town of Elberfeld, Duane
Erwin, Pres. & Stoltz Structural, Inc, Linda Stoltz, Pres. 27.52 acres
located on the N side of Seven Hills Rd. approximately 0’ N of the intersection
formed by Seven Hills Rd. (N 750) & St. Johns Rd. (W 1100), Greer Twp.
(Complete legal on file.) Advertised in the Boonville Standard
Duane
Erwin excused himself from the meeting due to a conflict of interest.
Attorney
Present
was Andy Easley, Engineer.
The
President called for a staff report.
Ms.
Phillips stated all return receipts from certified mail to the adjacent
property owners have been submitted. She stated the property is zoned “M-2”
General Industrial and there is no required lot area in that zoning. She stated
there is a 5’ setback from all lot lines. She stated this is a proposed 10 lot
industrial subdivision by the Town of
The
President asked if the applicant had anything to add to the staff report.
Mr.
Easley stated he did not.
The
President called for questions by the Board.
There
being no questions by the Board, the President called for remonstrators.
Robert
Oath stated he has a few questions. He stated he called but never really got
answers. He stated how is there a building permit already issued when it has
not passed through this process.
Ms.
Phillips stated this property is in an approved minor subdivision, and it has
gone through a minor subdivision process, and everyone was sent a notice of the
minor subdivision at that time, including Mr. Oath. She stated now they want to
create additional lots and build a road, so it is now going to be a major
subdivision.
Mr.
Oath stated the notice was sent to an address that has never existed for him
and he does not know where they would have gotten it. He stated how that
address got on a plot card he didn’t know and he didn’t receive the first one.
He stated the building permit was issued in February but they were moving dirt
before the first of the year, last fall. He stated nobody knew what was going
on over there. He stated last fall he was told by the President of the Town
Board of Elberfeld that there would be nothing built beyond the preexisting
building. He stated the lot they are proposing to build on is now running next
to his lot line. He stated there is an entrance right down next to his property
line. He stated there are kids in the area and there is going to be a steel
fabrication works right next to him. He stated know one can guarantee it is
going to be fenced or anything. He stated he was told only Stoltz was wanting 5
acres and they are asking to have 27.5 acres. He stated the description is not
correct on the blue prints, but that is probably a minor flaw.
The
President asked where the mistake in the legal description is.
Mr.
Oath stated on the fourth call it says you go East, which is across the road,
it should be South.
Ms.
Phillips stated is says it is going South 00ْ 10’ 41” East, 391’, that is South.
Mr.
Oath stated mine says East. He then stated one other concern is, before any one
who is now on the Town Board even lived in the area, there were water wells
drilled by the Town of
There
being no other remonstrators, the President asked if Mr. Easley would like to
comment on any of Mr. Oaths concerns.
Mr.
Easley stated he thinks all of the subdivisions done for the Town of
Robert
Addington asked how many wells were there.
Mr.
Oath stated there were seven.
Mr.
Easley stated these are old water wells and that is not serious.
Mr.
Oath stated it is when you get down in the old coal mine works.
Mr.
Easley stated there may be a small amount of methane around hog farms too.
Guy
Gentry asked where there was another entrance to the North, because the only
entrance he sees is off of
Ms.
Phillips stated what he is talking about is Stoltz got a commercial driveway
for a construction entrance. She stated after
Mr.
Willis asked if it was a temporary drive.
Ms.
Phillips stated it could be permanent, but it was her understanding they wanted
to come off of
Mr.
Gentry asked if there were plans for a barrier.
Mr.
Easley stated unless they are going to fence it, he does not know of any
screening that they are planning.
Ms.
Phillips stated they already have their building permit. She stated the
drainage plans were approved according to the agreement to clean out the ditch.
She stated right now it is not a legal drain so the County has no rights to fix
it or clean it and there is a ditch that runs into Blue Grass Creek that needs
some repairs. She stated in about 3 weeks it will become a legal drain.
Mr.
Addington asked where this comes into Blue Grass Creek.
Ms.
Phillips stated it is about 2 miles down.
Mr.
Easley stated the small creek is an unnamed tributary to Blue Grass Creek.
Ms.
Phillips stated as far as notification the regulations are to use the property
cards in the Auditor’s Office and that is what is used for legal addressing. She
stated if Mr. Oaths address is not right in there then he needs to correct it.
Attorney
Mr.
Gentry stated the Board can place conditions on a plat.
Attorney
Gary
Michel asked if the dark area on the surrounding area map is the area we are
talking about.
Mr.
Easley stated that was correct. He then showed the Board which lot the building
was being constructed on and the location of the proposed driveway off of the
proposed street.
Mr.
Michel stated so
Mr.
Easley stated that was correct they want to build it this summer.
Ms.
Phillips stated that is why they are trying to plat this subdivision.
Mr.
Michel asked how many lots were in the Minor Subdivision.
Ms.
Phillips stated there were three and now they are dividing up the property
further.
Mr.
Easley stated he has been working with Elberfeld for several years on the
master plan and it has changed a little based on the number of acres. He stated
Stoltz is signing this plat and owns 4.65 acres. He stated if we could have got
this done soon enough Stoltz would not have taken title until it had been
recorded.
Mr.
Michel asked if
Mr.
Easley stated yes.
Ascertaining
there were no other questions from the Board, the President called for a
motion.
Larry
Willis made a motion to find PP-04-06 Elberfeld Industrial Park in technical
conformity with the Subdivision Control Ordinance and to approve it. The motion
was seconded by Guy Gentry and unanimously carried.
Duane
Erwin returned to the meeting.
REZONING PETITIONS:
PC-R-04-12 – Petition of Herbert P.
Grimm and Robert E. Grimm to
rezone 19.81 acres located on the W side of Grimm Rd. approximately 850’ N of
the intersection formed by Grimm Rd. (W 1000) & Lincoln Ave. (S 450)., Ohio
Twp. from “A” Agriculture to “R-1A” Single Family Dwelling. (Complete legal on
file.) Advertised in the Boonville
Standard
Robert
Addington made a motion to withdraw PC-R-04-12 per the applicant’s request. The
motion was seconded by Larry Willis and unanimously carried.
PC-R-04-13 – Petition of Herbert P.
Grimm and Robert E. Grimm to
rezone 38.44 acres located on the W side of Grimm Rd. approximately 0’ SW of
the intersection formed by Grimm Rd. (W 1000)
& S.R. 66, Ohio Twp. from “A” Agriculture to “C-4” General Commercial.
(Complete legal on file.) Advertised in
the Boonville Standard
Present
were Herbert Grimm, Robert Grimm, and Bill Nicholson, Engineer.
The
President called for a staff report.
Ms.
Phillips stated all return receipts from certified mail to the adjacent
property owners have been submitted, except from Janet Zehr; however we do have
the white pay stub from the certified mailing. She stated this is a petition to
rezone 38.44 acres from “A” Agriculture to “C-4” General Commercial. She stated
the Comprehensive Plan shows the area to be Commercial and Agriculture. She
then stated the property is existing farm ground. She stated the surrounding
property to the North is zoned “C-4” General Commercial and “A” Agriculture and
vacant, to the South is zoned “A” Agriculture and vacant, to the East is zoned
“C-4” General Commercial and vacant, and to the West is “A” Agriculture and
“C-4” General Commercial with residences on them. She stated there is no flood
plain and access is from
The
President asked if the applicant had anything further to add to the staff
report.
Mr.
Grimm stated no, but there is “C-4” to the North, East, and West. He stated he
does not have any definite plans; they just want to establish the zoning on it.
Mr.
Nicholson stated there is an existing frontage road that comes off of
The
President called for questions by Board.
Mr.
Gentry asked if the frontage road is going to remain after the SR 66
construction is complete.
Mr.
Nicholson stated yes.
The
President called for remonstrators.
Scott
Jenkins stated his property is at the end of the frontage road. He stated he
owns all the way between two pieces of State property. He stated Mr. Grimm had
put a road across his property going from State property over his property and
over State property to access Mr. Grimm’s property. He stated the flag pole
like piece of property comes within 2 feet of the States property. He stated he
just started a little lawn mowing equipment business. He stated there is so
much equipment beside his house, torn up dirt, he wakes up on Saturdays and
Sundays to the sound of a bulldozer that has been running in the field behind
his house. He stated he cannot even see the end of Mr. Grimm’s property, but he
can hear it. He stated he does not know what is going on but he is here to object
to 38 acres being zoned “C-4”. He stated his property is not even a half acre
and the property across the street that is zoned commercial is not even an
acre. He stated the other piece that is zoned commercial is next to a subdivision.
He stated he moved there because he had no neighbors, he does not like
neighbors, and the property value will go down because of this.
There
being no other remonstrators, the President asked if the applicant would like
to address any of Mr. Jenkins concerns.
Mr.
Grimm stated Blankenberger Bros, Inc. has taken some dirt off the back for
Deaconess, about 20,000 yards. He stated the little dog leg out there at one
time was a right of way back to Mr. Jenkins house, as far as a deed for that;
he would just have to see it.
Ms.
Phillip stated according to the rezoning filed by Mr. Jenkins it does.
Mr.
Grimm stated according to the State he doesn’t.
Mr.
Gentry asked if currently Mr. Grimm is selling dirt to Blankenberger for
Deaconess and the matter of crossing of Mr. Jenkins right of way is a civil
issue.
Mr.
Grimm stated that was correct.
Mr.
Jenkins stated he said something to the guy doing the hauling and they have
stopped hauling across his property.
Mr.
Gentry stated that will still be a private civil issue and this Board will not
get involved in it.
Mr.
Addington asked what Mr. Grimm was planning for the “C-4” General Commercial.
Mr.
Grimm stated they have no plans at this point; they just want to establish the
zoning.
Mr.
Addington stated then they could put any of the listed uses there.
Ms.
Phillips stated they could only get one permit there unless they subdivide the
property. She then asked if there was anything on the property now.
Mr.
Grimm stated there was a house and barns.
Ms.
Phillips stated then they will not be able to get any permits until it is
subdivided, there is already a use on the property. She stated the property to
the East was just rezoned to “C-4”.
Mr.
Addington asked what the uses were going to be there.
Ms.
Phillips stated there were no plans across the front by SR 66, but the back was
going to be used for a synagogue.
There
being no other questions by the Board, the President called for a motion.
Larry
Willis made a motion to recommend approval to the
The President stated there being no other
motions, PC-R-04-13 will go to the July 14th
PC-R-04-14 – Petition of Herbert P.
Grimm and Robert E. Grimm to
rezone 8.79 acres located on the N side of Willow Pond Rd. approximately 936’ E
of the intersection formed by Grimm Rd. (W 1000) & Willow Pond Rd. (S 500), Ohio Twp. from
“A” Agriculture to “R-1A” Single Family Dwelling. (Complete legal on file.) Advertised in the Boonville Standard
Present
were Herbert Grimm, Robert Grimm, and Bill Nicholson, Engineer.
The
President called for a staff report.
Ms.
Phillips stated all return receipts from certified mail to the adjacent
property owners have been submitted, except from Timothy Gesselman and David
Ellerbush & Mary Joe Bischuff, however we do have the white pay stub from
the certified mailing. She stated this petition is to rezone 8.79 acres from
“A” Agriculture to “R-1A” Single Family Dwelling. She stated the Comprehensive
Plan shows this area to be moderate to high density residential. She stated the
existing land use is farm ground with the surrounding property to the North,
South, East, and West being zoned “A” Agriculture and vacant. She stated there
is no flood plain and the property does access off of Willow Pond Rd. She
stated the stated use is a residential subdivision. She stated all the
remaining zonings are in this area with the same property owners. She stated
they had to file separate petitions, because they are on separate deeds, but
the petitions are all to rezone to “R-1A” Single Family Dwelling.
Attorney
Mr.
Willis asked if the 4th parcel was across the street and if it was
still contiguous, but could they hear it at the same time as the rest.
Ms.
Phillips stated she thinks they could hear all four.
Mr.
Willis made a motion to listen to all four petitions at the same time, but vote
on them individually.
The
motion was seconded by Guy Gentry and unanimously carried.
PC-R-04-15 – Petition of Herbert P.
Grimm to rezone 7.93 acres
located on the E side of Grimm Rd. approximately 0’ NE of the intersection
formed by Grimm Rd. (W 1000) &
Willow Pond Rd. (S 500), Ohio Twp. from
“A” Agriculture to “R-1A” Single Family Dwelling. (Complete legal on file.) Advertised in the Boonville Standard
PC-R-04-16 – Petition of Herbert P.
Grimm to rezone 12.745 acres
located on the E side of Grimm Rd. approximately 526.37’ N of the intersection
formed by Grimm Rd. (W 1000) &
Willow Pond Rd. (S 500), Ohio Twp. from
“A” Agriculture to “R-1A” Single Family Dwelling. (Complete legal on file.) Advertised in the Boonville Standard
PC-R-04-17 – Petition of Herbert P.
Grimm to rezone 2 acres located on the W side of Grimm Rd.
approximately 0’ SW of the intersection formed by Grimm Rd. (W 1000) & Lockwood Lane, Ohio Twp. from “A”
Agriculture to “R-1A” Single Family Dwelling.
(Complete legal on file.) Advertised
in the Boonville Standard
Present
were Herbert Grimm, Robert Grimm, and Bill Nicholson, Engineer.
She stated the surrounding property is “A” Agriculture
and there are subdivisions almost adjacent to the properties. She stated all
the applications are all in order.
Mr. Michel asked how far down the property was from
Mr. Gentry stated 1630’.
Considerable discussion was held on which piece of
property was which petition.
Mr. Nicholson stated the property to the Southwest is
Kenosha Hills subdivision. He stated that subdivision was developed by the
Grimms and there is only 6 or 7 lots left in that subdivision. He stated the
homes proposed are going to be that or a little more.
Mr. Grimm stated more upscale, close to $300,000 to
$350,000.
Mr. Addington stated the home ranges will be around
$300,000.
Mr. Grimm stated that was correct.
Mr. Addington asked how many lots he was planning.
Mr. Grimm stated about 83.
Mr. Nicholson stated 75’ by 125’ average size lot.
Mr. Grimm stated there probably will not be a 75’ lot
they will probably be 80’ to 100’ lots.
Mr. Willis asked if this was going to all be one
subdivision or would it be separate ones.
Mr. Grimm stated they will all be tied together.
Mr. Gentry asked what the piece across the street was
going to be.
Mr. Grimm stated it may have part of the same name,
but will be different.
Mr. Willis asked if the School Board had long range
plans with all the subdivisions in this area.
Mr. Gentry stated they own 20 acres South of
Mr. Grimm stated he thinks they are going to have to
come out in the valley, there is no way to bring it out at the top of
Mr. Michel asked if Mr. Grimm was planning on 2
entrances.
Mr. Grimm stated probably.
Mr. Michel asked if Mr. Grimm was going to stub a road
out to the East.
Mr. Grimm stated he was.
Ms. Phillips stated since the property fronts on
Mr. Addington asked if the lots are bigger than the
required 75’ it would be less than 83 lots, so would there be 50.
Mr. Nicholson stated yes, it will.
There
being no further questions by the Board, the President called for a motion on
PC-R-04-14.
Duane Erwin made a motion to recommend
approval to the
The President called for a motion on
PC-R-04-15.
Larry Willis made a motion to recommend
approval to the
The President called for a motion on
PC-R-04-16.
Larry Willis made a motion to recommend
approval to the
The President called for a motion on
PC-R-04-17.
Larry Willis made a motion to recommend
approval to the
OTHER BUSINESS:
Payment
of Claim – Comprehensive Zoning
Ordinance update - BLA – $3,272.50
Ms.
Phillips stated this is for Bernardin, Lochmuller, and Associate, and
Attorney
Guy
Gentry made a motion to pay the claim. The motion was seconded by Larry Willis
and unanimously carried.
* * * * * * * * * *
Request for Extension of Plat - Warrick Research and Industrial Center No. 7
approved
Ms.
Phillips stated when someone files a primary plat you have 2 years to file a
final plat and 5 years to complete the entire development. She stated Kenny
Ubelhor is making the request.
Attorney
Ms.
Phillips stated right now it is two years and she is hoping it gets changed
back to 1 year. She stated a request for two more additional years is just too
long.
Attorney
Mr.
Gentry asked if they have the authority to ask for two years.
Ms.
Phillips stated you can ask for an extension.
Mr.
Gentry asked if there was a max time limit they can ask for and is if for
residential and/or industrial.
Ms.
Phillips stated they have two year and his time would not be up until
Mr.
Willis stated then he thinks Mr. Ubelhor needs to be present and explain why he
needs the extension.
Mr.
Willis made a motion to table the extension for Warrick Research and Industrial
Center No 7 approved
* * * * * * * * * *
Formal Complaint: Paul
& Barbara Cannon –
Present was Paul Cannon.
The President called for a staff
report.
Ms.
Phillips stated a formal complaint was filed on this piece of property on
Mr.
Cannon stated he is sorry he has not gotten done, but he has had some property
damage with trees coming down for the last couple weeks.
Ms.
Phillips stated with what is left, Mr. Cannon could get that cleaned up in one
day.
Mr.
Cannon stated he is trying to fix that one building so he can put his motor in
it.
Mr.
Willis asked if he could get it cleaned up by the next meeting.
Mr.
Cannon stated he could.
Robert
Addington made a motion to grant Mr. Cannon a 30 day extension. The motion was
seconded by Larry Willis seconded the motion and unanimously carried.
Formal Complaint: Edward
Broshears, Sr.,
Formal Complaint: Edward
Broshears, Jr.,
Present
were Edward Broshears, Sr. and Edward Broshears, Jr.
The
President called for a staff report.
Ms.
Phillips stated a formal complaint was filed on both pieces of property on
Mr.
Gentry stated we knew it would not be cleaned up by June 1, but hoped a lot
would be cleaned up. He then asked how much longer they think it will take.
Mr.
Broshears stated the big white truck sitting out front, they lost the motor in
that and have been trying to get a motor in it. He stated he would like to see
at least 3 more months. He has cows he has to take care of and he has to cut
some hay. He stated there are two loads waiting to be hauled off. He stated he
is going to put an electric fence around and let the cows clean up the yard.
Mr.
Willis asked when the meeting would be in September.
Ms.
Phillips stated September 8th.
Mr.
Willis made a motion to give both of the gentlemen until September 8th
to get the property cleaned up and give them time to fix the truck and cut
their hay. The motion was seconded by Robert Addington and unanimously carried.
* * * * * * * * * *
Formal Complaint: Marvin
Leroy Bruce & Jeanie Bruce,
Present
was Jeanie Bruce.
The
President called for a staff report.
Ms.
Phillips stated another formal complaint was filed on this of property on
Mrs.
Bruce stated the big van is licensed and the only thing the minivan needs is a
power steering pump.
Mr.
Willis stated she has come a long way.
Guy
Gentry stated he would like to make a motion to remove this from the agenda and
she is no longer in violation. He stated he is really astounded and hopes she
maintains it in the condition it is currently in.
Mrs.
Bruce stated she still has work to do, but she wants to up a privacy fence to
keep the babies from going out to the road.
The
motion was seconded by Larry Willis and unanimously carried.
ATTORNEY
BUSINESS: None
EXECUTIVE
DIRECTOR BUSINESS:
Budget
Ms.
Phillips stated she would send a copy to the Board Members, but normally we
turn in a 10% raise, and then the council gives us what they can. She stated
there is nothing special she is asking for. She stated if anyone has any
questions before July 5th, just call her.
* * * * * * * * * *
Ms.
Phillips stated she did ask for an additional from the Council for a
transcriber. She stated the one we have now is broke and is 13 years old. She
stated there is only one type of transcriber you can use with this recording
device and they cost $1095.00.
Mr.
Addington asked who purchased the recording equipment.
Ms.
Phillips stated it was probably the Auditor’s Office or the Commissioners. She
stated but you have to buy it from VanAusdall & Farrar.
Being
no other business, the meeting adjourned at
Guy
Gentry, President
ATTEST:
Sherri
Phillips, Executive Director
and
Secretary